In Herring v. The Queen and related cases, the appeals of a number of different people who had ‘invested’ in the Banyan Tree Foundation’s ‘leveraged donation program’ were dismissed. These investments, what CRA used to call “abusive charity gifting tax shelters,” go back to around 2002, and it is unfortunate that the TCC is so slow in disposing of them.
The judgement notes “These appeals are “lead cases” pursuant to section 146.1 of the Tax Court of Canada Rules (General Procedure), SOR/90-688a. Approximately 328 taxpayers, including the Appellants, have agreed to be bound by the results herein.”. Anyone interested in public policy relating to the charity sector should certainly read the case – it shows how some people have a very different view of charitable donations than other people. It also explains some of the Department of Finance’s reticence to add more tax benefits when people donate to registered charities.
You can read the original judgement above or on the TCC website.
There is also another decision relating to the Banyan Tree namely Crane v. The King. [PDF] Mr. Crane had invested in the Banyan Tree Program. What is interesting is that he is a retired judge of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice and he invested in the scheme while he was a judge. In this case, similar to Herring above, the TCC judge determined that there was no gift and dismissed the appeal.
Related Posts
May 12, 2024
CRA reminds charities that that you can carry out activities outside of Canada but if you do, then you need to comply with the rules
The CRA has reminded charities that they can engage in foreign activities, but there are rules regarding how such activities are carried out. For…
May 6, 2024
Canada Proposes new “Foreign Influence Transparency Registry” under the proposed Foreign Influence Transparency and Accountability Act (FITAA)
Today, the Federal Liberal Government proposed Bill C-70 An Act respecting countering foreign interference. Here is the text of Bill C-70 In the…
April 25, 2024
Ontario Government reduces reporting by charities in Ontario to Ontario Public Guardian and Trustee
In October 2023, we wrote a blog entitled “Ontario Government proposing to remove requirement for charities to notify the OPGT when established”. It…